Join our mailing list!






You are here:Home > Mike's Pies
Sort By:
Page of 1
Heath Bar Crunch Pie
Our Price: $22.00

What do you get when you top a rich chocolate crust with a creamy filling chocked full of crisp toffee pieces?
Mike tops off this yummy concoction with crushed Heath Bars and drizzles the top with Chocolate Ganache and Carmel. This 2002 National Award Winner is a candy lovers dream come true.

Not Available For Shipping.
Local Pick Up Only.

Mississippi Mud Pie
Our Price: $22.00

It’s Mike at his decadent best!
Mike whips up a fluffy coffee mousse and piles it onto a chocolate cookie crust, and tops it off with a rich, thick chocolate topping.

Not Available For Shipping.
Local Pick Up Only.

Key Lime Pie 11 inch
Our Price: $22.00

If you want the true taste of an "Island Style" Key Lime Pie, this is it! A True "Island Style" Key Lime Pie! We start by making the graham cracker crust with our own recipe and fill it with our "Killer" Key Lime filling made with pasteurized egg yolks, condensed milk and "Nellie & Joe's" Key Lime Juice! That's it!! No preservatives, no artificial ingredients and no Jell-O! We bake it, we cool it and then we freeze it! When it thaws it tastes like you just made it, only Mike did!

Not Available For Shipping.
Local Pick Up Only.

Reese's Peanut Butter Pie
Our Price: $22.00

Our light and creamy filling is made with Reese's® peanut butter and topped with Reese's Peanut Butter Cups®.
Then Mike pours it on with a drizzle of Chocolate Ganache and Caramel! All this sits in a rich chocolate graham cracker crust, made with Hershey's® Cocoa. Be careful...this Two Time National Champion could give your sweet tooth a cramp!

Not Available For Shipping.
Local Pick Up Only.

Southern Pecan Pie
Our Price: $22.00

This is the Pie that makes Mike's Grandma proud!
A third generation recipe, it begins with a flaky pastry crust packed to the max with the best Pecans you'll ever taste (not those scrawny little pieces, but big fat halves.) Next comes our award winning filling...that's right...this too is a National Champ! Then it's baked to perfection!! Remember, all Pecan Pies are not created equal!

Not Available For Shipping.
Local Pick Up Only.

Apple Crisp Pie
Our Price: $25.00

Just Like Grandma used to make!
We combine tart apples with just the right amount of sugar and cinnamon and a buttery crumb topping. Can you say “comfort food?”

Not Available For Shipping.
Local Pick Up Only.

New York Style Cheesecake Pie
Our Price: $25.00

This is the real deal!
Following that authentic style, it's cooked in a water bath and the pan is dusted with toasted breadcrumbs. Can you say Cream Cheese? That's the only cheese you'll find in our bad boy!

Not Available For Shipping.
Local Pick Up Only.

Sea Salt Caramel Cheesecake
Our Price: $25.00

Just when you thought you have tasted the best cheesecake ever Mike's Pies has raised the bar again. We have taken this ever-so-popular flavor and has set the standard for all "SSCC's". We start with our NY Cheesecake and swirl in thick, rich caramel. As if that wasn't enough we top it with a thin layer of HERSHEY's(c) Caramel Topping. Where is the Sea Salt? We lightly sprinkle the top of the cheesecake with a light dusting of Sea Salt before pouring on the Caramel topping. Put it all together and you have a dessert that will "blow your mind"!

Not Available For Shipping.
Local Pick Up Only.

Turtle Cheesecake
Our Price: $25.00

This is the Mike’s Pies version of a Turtle Cheesecake. By appearance it looks like all the others, chocolate, caramel, pecans, etc.… but when you bite into it you will agree it is totally different. We pour our magical mixture into our made from scratch chocolate cookie crust and cook in a water bath to give you a cheesecake that melts in your mouth. No fillers or preservatives added.

Not Available For Shipping.
Local Pick Up Only.